Couch Comparisons

AllModern vs Medley: Who Has Better Couches?

Looking for the perfect couch contender? Explore the duel between AllModern and Medley, and discover which brand secures the crown for your next cozy addition.
AllModern vs Medley

We independently select everything we recommend. When you buy through our links, we may earn a commission.

Step right up, folks, as we introduce the contenders in the grand contest of comfort: AllModern and Medley. With promises of style and durability, these brands bring their A-game to the couch showdown. Prepare to be amazed as we delve into the world of trendy designs and top-notch craftsmanship!

Side By Side

Features
AllModern
Medley
Made to Order Lead Times 3-5 weeks 8+ weeks
Free Shipping Option
White Glove Delivery Option $149.99 $175
Return Option
Warranty Included
Financing Option Affirm / Bread Pay / AllModern Credit Card Affirm
Assembly Required Varies
Large Fabric Selection
Free Swatches Available
Manufacturing Origin USA + Import USA
Avg. 3-Seat Couch Price $$ $$$-$$$$

In the battle of AllModern versus Medley, the decision boils down to personal preferences. AllModern shines with a wide range of styles at affordable prices, appealing to budget-conscious buyers, while Medley sets itself apart with top-notch quality, sustainability, and craftsmanship. Medley's dedication to eco-friendly materials and exceptional warranties makes it a premium choice for those valuing sustainability over budget-friendly options. When choosing between the two, it's all about style, quality, and eco-conscious decisions.


BRAND #1: AllModern

The image shows the AllModern logo. The word "ALL" is written in thin black capital letters, and "MODERN" is in bold black capital letters. The text is centered on a white background.

Founded in 2006, AllModern revolutionized the online furniture market with its wide selection of modern designs. Now owned by Wayfair, AllModern continues to offer affordable furniture options, including both imported and USA-made couches. Their focus on convenience and affordability appeals to a broad range of customers. While they may lack a cohesive brand identity and could improve transparency regarding materials and construction, AllModern remains a popular destination for those seeking trendy furniture at accessible prices.

AllModern | Brand Summary

AllModern seems to have two clashing identities. On the surface, AllModern appears to be a place to shop for affordable furniture, offering inexpensive but trendy couches that are relatively well-priced (All Modern Furniture is owned by Wayfair, after all). But beneath that is a company that custom builds couches in the USA. These are surprisingly high quality considering the low price tag.

Yet you might never know the second option exists due to the way AllModern furniture hides it on their site. If I were only rating their made in the USA couches, they’d probably be closer to a 92%. But when you factor in the abundance of imported, lower-quality couches that are actually on display, an 85% feels more appropriate.

AllModern | PotatoMeter Rating:

Online Shopping Experience Score 87%
Durability and Quality Score 82%
Shipping and Lead Time Score 94%
Vibe Check Score 78%
Customer Focus Score 82%
Overall PotatoMeter Rating 85%
Read Our AllModern Brand Review

AllModern | Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Wide range of affordable and trendy couches
  • Fast shipping for in-stock items
  • Free white glove delivery on many sofas
  • Variety of financing options available
  • 3-year warranty on frames (for USA-made couches)
  • Mortise and tenon joints in USA-made couches

Cons

  • Potentially inconsistent quality for 3rd party couches
  • 30-day return window with potential fees
  • Lack of transparency regarding materials and construction for some couches
  • No free shipping on all couches
  • Limited fabric swatch options for some couches

AllModern is a haven for budget-minded shoppers seeking a trendy new sofa. Their vast selection spans a wide range of styles and colors, ensuring you'll find something that speaks to your unique taste. With in-stock couches shipping out in as little as two days and free white-glove delivery on many models, your new centerpiece could be gracing your living room in no time. Those opting for one of their USA-made couches can rest easy knowing they come with a 3-year warranty and are constructed with durable mortise and tenon joints.

However, navigating AllModern's offerings requires a discerning eye. While their USA-made sofas generally boast good quality, their third-party couches can be a mixed bag. Some lack detailed information about materials and construction, making it difficult to assess their long-term durability. Additionally, the 30-day return window might feel a bit short, especially with the potential for restocking fees and the responsibility of return shipping falling on the customer.

Despite these caveats, All Modern Furniture remains an appealing option for those who prioritize style and affordability. With a little research and careful consideration of the specific sofa model, you can find a stylish and functional piece that fits your budget and lifestyle. Just be aware that their offerings might not satisfy those seeking the highest-quality materials or a hassle-free return experience.

Shop AllModern Now

BRAND #2: Medley

The image displays the word "medley" in lowercase letters, written in a simple, thin serif font on a plain white background.

Medley was founded in 2017 by two brothers, Travis and Ryan Nagle. But their story actually begins in 2005 when they were selling sofas out of their living room. They are one of the only couch companies offering ultra-green material options.

Medley | Brand Summary

Medley is a rare company that actually delivers on its promises of top-of-the-line craftsmanship, all-natural material options, and sustainability. They offer an excellent, hand-crafted product, but their prices can be a bit too high for the average consumer and their lead times can be excessive. Medley was founded with a mission to create eco friendly furniture that not only lasts but also minimizes harmful chemicals and toxins, catering to consumers who prioritize environmental mindfulness in their purchasing decisions.

But if you want a made in the USA couch with wonderfully-natural materials, lifetime warranties, and a competitive price point, then Medley should be the first place you look. And chances are it will be the only place you have to look.

Medley | PotatoMeter Rating

Online Shopping Experience Score 90%
Durability and Quality Score 97%
Shipping and Lead Time Score 84%
Vibe Check Score 97%
Customer Focus Score 95%
Overall PotatoMeter Rating 93%
Read Our Medley Brand Review

Medley | Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Latex + Wool eco-friendly options
  • All couches made in the USA
  • Extremely high quality materials and craftsmanship
  • Lifetime warranty on sofa frames and 5+ year warranty on materials
  • Generous 30 day return policy

Cons

  • Limited sofa style options
  • Fabric selection can significantly raise sofa price
  • Latex + Wool option can be pricey
  • Lead times can be extremely long
  • No brick-and-mortar stores

It can be hard to find any flaws in Medley’s business. But while their standard couches usually have lead times of 8-10 weeks (not counting delivery), their wonderful Latex + Wool options often take 14+ weeks to build. That’s a long time to wait, especially when there are no brick-and-mortar stores where you can test out their couches. Their base prices are great considering the high-quality materials and craftsmanship, but choosing a higher-tier fabric and their natural Latex + Wool materials will significantly raise the sofa price. But they’ll still be cheaper than Maiden Home’s offerings. Medley’s styles are nice, but they might be a little bland, depending on your tastes.

However, the pros vastly outweigh the cons. Their plant-based Latex + Wool material options are incredible and put Medley in a class of its own. Their wood is sourced from sustainable forests, their fabrics are eco-friendly, and every aspect of their construction process considers the sustainability impact. They also use a high-quality spring system similar to 8-way hand-tied suspensions. This is top-tier craftsmanship. Their frames also come with a lifetime warranty, the cushion filling has a 10-year warranty, and the upholstery workmanship has a 5-year warranty. Add in their 30-day return policy and there’s a whole lot to like about Medley.

Shop Medley Now

And the winner is...

In the realm of couch royalty, Medley emerges victorious as the ultimate winner. With a commitment to sustainability, exceptional craftsmanship, and eco-friendly materials, Medley offers a premium experience that outshines the competition. If you seek enduring quality and luxurious comfort, Medley proves to be an unparalleled choice, setting a new standard in the world of home furniture.

A smiling man with short brown hair and a beard stands on a beach during sunset. He is wearing a black short-sleeved shirt with small white dots. The ocean and sandy shore are in the background, creating a warm and relaxed atmosphere.
Alex Back
Couch.com CEO & Founder
Alex Back is the founder and CEO of Couch.com. Previously, he was the co-founder and COO of the popular furniture brand, Apt2B, which was acquired by a large US retail furniture chain in 2018. He worked to integrate Apt2B, one of the very first online furniture retailers on the Shopify platform, into the operations of the 100 year old larger business entity and was deeply immersed in the business operations of both online and brick and mortar retail for 4 years before leaving in 2023 to start Couch.com. Working in various parts of the furniture industry since 2004, he has 20 years experience in retail sales, e-commerce, marketing, operations, logistics and wholesale manufacturing and distribution. He has worked extensively with partners such as Costco, Bed Bath and Beyond and Amazon and his work has been highlighted in many publications such as Forbes, CNN and HGTV, among others. Alex is delighted to bring his experience and authority on couches and the furniture industry to this platform, along with many of his industry colleagues who are helping him keep the Couch.com audience informed and engaged on a daily basis.
Expand