Side-By-Side Comparison:
Article vs Castlery
Features
Article
Castlery
Based on the chart it’s hard to tell that Article and Castlery are even two different companies. But once we look at the nitty gritty details some of the similarities disappear.
While both of these companies offer warranties, Article only has a 1 year warranty on their couches compared to Castlery’s 3 year warranty on sofa frames and 1 year warranty on material craftsmanship. Castlery has the edge on this one.
When it comes to returns, Article provides a 30 day free return window. You can also choose to exchange your couch for a different one. On the other hand, Castlery has a 14 day return window and the customer has to pay a 20% return fee. It’s also important to note that there might be a $149 (or more) delivery fee for Castlery sofas depending on your location. Both of these factors are huge points in Article’s favor.
Still can’t decide? Let’s break it down even further.
Brand Focus: Article
Article
Article is a Canadian company that was founded in 2013. They proudly state that their brand values are, "Customer obsession, do it differently, ownership mindset, win together." They helped pioneer the online couch market and they're still a major player in the sofa space. Plus, being Canadian, they ship to Canada!
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
High style at low prices In-Stock couches ship very fast Ships to Canada Has a 4.5 star rating on TrustPilot Solid wood frame construction Generous return options |
Couches manufactured in Asia Only a 1 year warranty Limited fabric selection No brick-and-mortar locations |
Pros & Cons: Article
Article is really punching above their weight class when it comes to offering stylish sofas at budget friendly prices. Even better, their sofas are generally all constructed using solid wood frames. That’s great at this price point. Article also has exceptionally fast lead times for their couches, aiming to deliver to your home within 2 weeks. On top of that, they have a tremendous and generous return policy. One bonus is that Article also ships to Canada. We think Article offers excellent value for their quality. But don’t just take our word for it. Article has a stellar 4.5 star rating on TrustPilot. Nice!
That being said, Article’s fast lead times and budget couches are made possible thanks to manufacturing their sofas in Asia. This also means that Article has a limited fabric selection and does not have made to order couches. Despite their exceptional return policy, Article only has a 1 year warranty on their couches, which isn’t ideal at this price point. Article also cuts costs by not having any brick-and-mortar locations or showrooms. But none of these downsides are enough for us to steer you away from Article’s excellent selection of sofas.
PotatoMeter Ratings
Article
The PotatoMeter is Couch.com’s very own rating system that grades furniture retailers on a variety of essential criteria.
Brand Focus: Castlery
Castlery
Castlery was founded in 2013 with the goal of making designer furniture accessible to everyone. Their imported, direct to consumer model has allowed them to achieve that goal, as evidenced by their stylish selection of sofas at affordable prices.
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
|
High style at low prices In-Stock couches ship very fast 3 year warranty on sofa frames Affordable add-on delivery options Has a 3.6 star rating on TrustPilot |
Couches manufactured in Asia 20% return fee Limited fabric selection No free delivery option outside select cities Plywood and LVL sofa frames No brick-and-mortar locations |
Pros & Cons: Castlery
Again, it can be hard to spot the differences between Castlery and Article’s pros and cons. Just like Article, Castlery offers stylish sofas at low prices. And Castlery’s in-stock couches ship incredibly fast. They also stand behind their products with a 3 year warranty on their sofa frames. That’s great for the price point. Castlery has a free front-door delivery option, but you can also add Room of Choice delivery for only $50 – $70 depending on zip code. Castlery has a lower rating on TrustPilot than Article, but a 3.6 star rating is still incredibly good for an online-only furniture company. Overall Castlery offers great options for customers.
Unfortunately it’s not all sunshine and roses for Castlery. While they do have affordable delivery options, they’re not as affordable if you live outside select cities. Front Door Delivery costs can be upwards of $199 in some areas. And this option doesn’t include White Glove or Room of Choice service. With a 20% return fee, the costs can suddenly start to really add up if you don’t love your couch. Like Article, Castlery’s construction takes place in Asia. This also limits the number of fabric options you can choose from. Their frames are also typically constructed using plywood and LVL (laminated veneer lumber). This should still be sturdy, but it makes Castlery’s price point less impressive. All that being said, Castlery is still a great option at this price range.
PotatoMeter Ratings
Castlery
The PotatoMeter is Couch.com’s very own rating system that grades furniture retailers on a variety of essential criteria.
And The Winner Is...
This one’s a real close call. They both offer a very similar selection of stylish sofas at extremely similar price points. If you value warranties, Castlery is a good option. If you prefer a solid wood frame then Article is a better choice. When it comes to free shipping and generous returns, Article is also the superior option. But it’s hard to go wrong with either of these affordable couch companies.
Want more comparisons? Check out these articles:
